Serta iComfort vs Douglas Mattress Review (2025)

Top Pick 2025

Rating

?

Informed by third-party engineer testing commissioned by GoodMorning.com.
Learn more >

9.9 /10

Price Range$599 – $899

Sleep Trial365 Nights

Warranty20 Years

Douglas Original

Meet the Mattress

Douglas Original is a popular Canadian-made foam mattress with a cooling gel comfort layer, excellent motion isolation and pressure-point relief, priced at just $799 for a queen. It’s part of Douglas’s Canadian-made lineup, and it comes with a 365-night sleep trial and a 20-year warranty. Douglas Original is also our top pick for Best Overall Mattress of 2025.

OFFERS AVAILABLE!

BONUS OFFERS WITH PURCHASE! Buy any Douglas mattress today and get a FREE Comfort Sleep Bundle + Duvet, 50% OFF Bedding and 20% OFF Bed Frames. See website for details >

Shop Douglas Read Review

vs

Rating

?

Informed by third-party engineer testing commissioned by GoodMorning.com.
Learn more >

4.0 /10

Price Range$2,389 – $3,049

Sleep Trial90

Warranty10 Years

Serta iComfort Hybrid ProHD Vanguard 2.0

Meet the Mattress

Priced at $2,399 for a queen size, the Serta iComfort Hybrid ProHD Vanguard 2.0 is a firm hybrid mattress available through The Brick in Canada. This 14″ inch Euro-top mattress is backed by a 100-night exchange-only trial and a 10-year warranty, though returns require coordination through The Brick and may include delivery charges.

Read Review

Douglas and Serta are two well-known names in the Canadian mattress market. Douglas Original is a medium-firm foam mattress with strong motion isolation and edge support. It’s a solid choice for sleepers who want a mattress that minimizes partner movement and feels stable around the edges.

Douglas is sold online and ships free to most addresses in Canada. It comes with a 365-night sleep trial, free returns, and a 20-year warranty. At $799 for a queen, it’s more affordable than the Serta iComfort. It also comes in more sizes, including RV options.

The Serta iComfort Hybrid ProHD Vanguard 2.0 hybrid mattress is sold through The Brick. In third-party testing, it scored well for edge support and motion isolation. It has a firm feel, which is good for back and stomach sleepers. A queen costs $2,399 and comes with a 10-year limited warranty. The Brick offers a 90-night sleep trial, but refunds are not available. You can only exchange for store credit, and return shipping costs apply.

If you’re trying to decide between Serta iComfort vs Douglas, we’ve put together a detailed comparison to help you choose.

Top Pick 2025

Made in

?

The manufacturing origin listed here is based on the law label of the specific mattress we tested. Learn more >

Winner

Douglas Original

Top-Rated Canadian Foam Mattress

Our Rating

?

Informed by third-party engineer testing commissioned by GoodMorning.com.
Learn more >

9.9/10

Douglas Original has a higher overall rating than Serta iComfort, according to our scoring methodology that factors in commissioned third-party engineer testing and over 40 other criteria.

BONUS OFFERS WITH PURCHASE! Buy any Douglas mattress today and get a FREE Comfort Sleep Bundle + Duvet, 50% OFF Bedding and 20% OFF Bed Frames. See website for details >

Read Review Shop Now

Where Douglas Shines

• Affordably priced starting at just $599
• 365-night sleep trial and 20-year warranty
• Made in Canada
• Comes with a free bedding bundle
• Great motion isolation and very good edge support
• Free shipping and returns for most Canadians

Publication Features

Canadian Living

Best Overall Mattress 2025

Style At Home

Best Mattress Canada 2025

Forbes

Best Mattress In a Box 2024

Overall Ratings

We include edge support and motion isolation in our overall mattress score, and we present these results using a simple colour system: green (5.0 and above), yellow (3.0–4.9), and red (2.9 and below). Cooling features aren’t part of the final rating, but we still use the same colour scale to show how each mattress performs. Firmness and bounce are more a matter of personal preference, so we display those scores in grey and exclude them from the overall score.

Motion Isolation

8.3

/10

Edge Support

7.8

/10

Cooling Features

5.0

/10

Firmness

6.7

/10

Bounce

3.1

/10

Mattress Overview

Product Details: Douglas Original

Douglas Original is a medium-firm gel foam mattress designed for comfort in any sleep position. It contours to your body for pressure relief while providing balanced support. With very good edge support to prevent slipping and great motion isolation, it's built to help you sleep undisturbed. The mattress also uses eco-conscious materials, including ecoLight® cooling gel foam and plant-based Infinitex™ fibres.

At $799 for a queen, the Douglas Original mattress is one of the more accessibly priced foam mattresses in Canada. It comes with a 365-night sleep trial during which you can return your mattress for free. The company also provides free return pickup, a 20-year warranty, and a free bedding bundle, which includes a cotton sheet set, down alternative duvet, pillow(s), pillow protector(s), and a mattress protector. For extra cooling or enhanced pressure relief, you can also check out the upgraded Douglas Alpine or Douglas Summit models.

Product Details: Serta iComfort

The Serta iComfort Hybrid ProHD Vanguard 2.0 is a firm hybrid mattress with a Euro-top design. It combines gel-infused foam, additional foam layers, and five-zoned pocketed coils to provide support and pressure relief. It's designed to reduce motion transfer, making it a good option for couples, and the pocketed coil system helps with edge support.

A queen-size Serta iComfort is priced at $2,399 and includes a 10-year limited warranty. It comes with a 90-night exchange-only trial. Returns must be coordinated through The Brick and may include delivery charges.

Get the mattress with the cooling, machine-washable cover.

Shop Douglas

Mattress Sizes & Prices

^{Prices are pulled from mattress brand websites or trusted third-party retailers. We check prices monthly to stay accurate. Prices on our site don't reflect any current sales or promotions. Learn more >}

Save big on your mattress when you buy a Douglas.

Shop Douglas

Mattress Construction

These two mattresses have different constructions. Douglas Original is an all-foam option with 3 layers, sitting at 10", while Serta iComfort is a 14", 6 layer hybrid mattress.

Douglas Original

• 1st Layer: 2" ecoLight® cooling gel foam to offer a memory-foam-like feel, which provides body-contouring comfort and pressure relief. The cooling gel infusion also makes this layer breathable and cool to the touch.
• 2nd Layer: 2" Elastex® transition foam, which adds a level of bounciness and responsiveness similar to latex, while being latex-free.
• 3rd Layer: 6" of motion-isolation support foam that provides support, stability, and significantly reduces motion transfer across the mattress. This high-density base helps to minimize disturbances from movements on the other side of the bed, which is one reason why all Douglas mattresses are known for their great motion isolation.

The Douglas Original has a white, mountainscape cover with a bold red zipper along the side. The top cover is removable and machine-washable, which makes it easy to clean. It's made with Infinitex™ fibres to wick away moisture and help keep the surface cool and breathable. The stretch-knit fabric feels soft to the touch and is very durable.

Serta iComfort

• 1st Layer: 0.5" cooling gel foam that contours to your body and helps draw heat away for a cooler sleep surface.
• 2nd Layer: 1″ Serta PillowSoft® Gel Foam that adds plushness and extra pressure relief.
• 3rd Layer: 0.5″ unidentified transition foam for support from the layers below
• 4th Layer: 3″ dense unidentified transition foam designed to prevent sinkage into the coils.
• 5th Layer: 8.5″ pocketed coils in five body zones for targeted support, with edge foam for added stability.
• 6th Layer: 0.5″ of base foam that provides a supportive foundation and protects the mattress from your bed frame.

The Serta iComfort mattress cover features a stylish two-tone design, combining white and navy blue. The top of the mattress showcases a white surface with a hexagonal quilted pattern, while the sidewalls are adorned with navy blue fabric accented by piping.

This "Cool Touch" top cover is made with polyester and polypropylene, plus a layer of phase-change material in the top layer to help with temperature control. Silver is also woven into the fabric for antimicrobial protection. The cover isn't removable or machine washable, so you should spot-clean any stains or spills.

Mattress Performance

In third-party engineer testing that we commissioned, the Douglas Original landed in the medium-firm range with a firmness score of 6.7/10, a firmness that works well for most sleep positions. By comparison, the Serta iComfort scored 7.5/10, placing it in the firm category. This makes it a good option for back and stomach sleepers who want extra support, though it may create pressure points for side sleepers or lighter individuals.

Both mattresses also tested well for motion isolation and edge support. Strong motion isolation helps prevent partner movement from disturbing your sleep, while solid edge support makes it easier to sit or lie near the sides without slipping off. Douglas earned higher scores compared to the Serta iComfort in both categories.

Where Douglas Differs:

• Douglas Original has a lower 3.1/10 bounce score, which means the top surface is less responsive. That can be helpful for light sleepers.
• Douglas also has a higher 8.3/10 motion isolation score, as well as a higher edge support score of 7.8/10, which is good if you sleep with a partner or pets.

Where Serta iComfort Differs:

• Serta iComfort has a higher 5.7/10 bounce score, which may be appealing if you prefer a responsive feel when changing positions or getting in and out of bed.

Delivery & Other Policies

Douglas

Douglas uses FedEx to deliver their mattresses directly to customers in most parts of Canada, usually within 2–10 business days. Its mattresses come with a 365-night sleep trial and 20-year warranty.

If you decide to return your Douglas mattress during the trial, pickup is free, and you'll get a full refund. Returned mattresses are either donated to local charities or responsibly recycled if donation isn't an option in your area.

Serta iComfort

The Serta iComfort Hybrid ProHD Vanguard 2.0 is sold through The Brick, with shipping costs varying depending on your location. The Brick does not provide an estimated delivery window. The mattress arrives fully expanded and wrapped in a single layer of plastic. Delivery includes bringing it to your room of choice, but setup isn't included.

The mattress comes with 90-night sleep trial, which is slightly shorter than the industry standard of 90 nights. If it isn't a good fit, you can exchange it for another mattress at The Brick, but you won't get a refund. You will receive store credit instead, and return shipping costs are your responsibility. This mattress is backed by a 10-year warranty.

Company Background

Third-party review sites like the Better Business Bureau (BBB) and Trustpilot collect and publish customer feedback about companies and their products, and aren't controlled by the companies being reviewed. They offer a snapshot of overall customer satisfaction and highlight common issues shoppers might face. Checking ratings on sites like these can be a useful way for customers to make more informed purchasing decisions.

While Serta is an older brand with a long and well-established presence in the mattress industry, it doesn't rate well on third-party review sites. Douglas has a better rating on Trustpilot, and its parent company, GoodMorning.com, rated well on BBB.

Douglas earns high marks from customers on BBB and Trustpilot. Find out why.

Shop Douglas

Final Recommendation

When comparing the Serta iComfort Hybrid ProHD Vanguard 2.0 to the Douglas Original, both mattresses offer supportive construction and good edge support. However, the Douglas mattress takes the lead with superior performance in cooling and motion isolation, all for a lower price.

Douglas includes a 365-night sleep trial, giving you a full year to test the mattress in your own home. It also comes with a 20-year warranty, free returns, and a complimentary bedding bundle with every purchase. At $799 for a queen, Douglas delivers a solid performance without a high price tag.

Serta iComfort, on the other hand, is sold through The Brick and comes with a 90-night trial, with exchanges only for store credit rather than a refund. Its warranty is also shorter at just 10 years of coverage. Delivery and returns can involve extra steps and costs depending on your location. If you want a longer trial and warranty, and free returns with a full refund, the Douglas Original is a strong choice.

Other Beds You Might Like

Best Hybrid

Logan & Cove Choice

Rating:

9.6/10

Price Range:

$799 - $1,299

Mattress Type:

Hybrid

Firmness Options:

Medium-firm

Country of Origin

Made In

?

The manufacturing origin listed here is based on the law label of the specific mattress we tested. Learn more >

Read Review

Best Sleep

Octave Vista

Rating:

9.7/10

Price Range:

$699 - $1,199

Mattress Type:

Memory Foam

Firmness Options:

Medium-firm

Country of Origin

Made In

?

The manufacturing origin listed here is based on the law label of the specific mattress we tested. Learn more >

Read Review

Top Pick 2025

Douglas Alpine

Rating:

9.8/10

Price Range:

$799 - $1,099

Mattress Type:

Foam

Firmness Options:

Medium-firm

Country of Origin

Made In

?

The manufacturing origin listed here is based on the law label of the specific mattress we tested. Learn more >

Read Review

Sponsored Ad