Casper vs Simba vs Douglas Mattress Review (2025)
Updated: October 14, 2025 | Published: August 13, 2025
Douglas Original
Meet the Mattress
Douglas Original is a popular Canadian-made foam mattress with a cooling gel comfort layer, excellent motion isolation and pressure-point relief, priced at just $799 for a queen. It’s part of Douglas’s Canadian-made lineup, and it comes with a 365-night sleep trial and a 20-year warranty. Douglas Original is also our top pick for Best Overall Mattress of 2025.
BONUS OFFERS WITH PURCHASE! Buy any Douglas mattress today and get a FREE Comfort Sleep Bundle, 50% OFF All Sheets, and 15% OFF All Bed Frames and Bedding. See website for details >
The Casper
Meet the Mattress
The Casper is a 3-layer memory foam mattress from Casper Canada, a brand owned by Sleep Country. Priced at $1,499 for a queen, it has a medium-firm feel, and comes with a 100-night sleep trial and a 10-year warranty. It’s available to buy online from either Casper or Sleep Country, and also in-store at Sleep Country locations.
Simba 2500
Meet the Mattress
The Simba 2500 is a hybrid mattress with foam and micro-coils, available online at Simba’s Canadian website and at Sleep Country Canada. It has good motion isolation and edge support, as well as 7-zone support in its base layer. As Simba’s intermediate-level mattress, it sells for $2,199 for a queen, more than some other hybrids on the market.
Douglas, Casper, and Simba are three well-known Canadian mattress brands. The Douglas Original and The Casper are medium-firm foam mattresses, while Simba 2500 is a medium-firm hybrid made with coils and foam. All three are made in Canada and have good motion isolation.
In this three-way comparison, Douglas Original scored an overall 9.9/10, beating The Casper at 5.8/10 and Simba 2500 at 6.1/10. Douglas stands out for offering similar or better features at a much lower price, its longer 365-night sleep trial and 20-year warranty, plus strong customer feedback.
A queen-size Casper costs $1,499 and comes with a 100-night sleep trial and a 10-year warranty. Simba 2500 sells for $2,199 and includes the same trial length and warranty, though Simba’s return policy is exchange-only. Douglas is the most affordable of these three mattresses at $799 for a queen. It includes a longer 365-night sleep trial, a 20-year warranty, and a free bedding bundle.
If you’re not sure which mattress is the best fit for you, we’ve laid out a detailed comparison to help you decide.
The manufacturing origin listed here is based on the law label of the specific mattress we tested. Learn more >
Winner:
Douglas Original
Top-Rated Canadian Foam Mattress
Douglas Original outperformed Simba 2500 and The Casper in head-to-head mattress comparison, based on our scoring methodology that includes third-party engineer testing (commissioned by us) and more than 40 criteria that shoppers care about most.
-
Longest sleep trial of 365 nights - Longest warranty of 20 years
- More cooling features than Casper Original and Simba 2500
- Machine-washable top cover
- Best-in-class motion isolation
- Free bedding bundle included
Canadian Living
Best Overall Mattress 2025
Style At Home
Best Mattress Canada 2025
Forbes
Best Mattress In a Box 2024
We include edge support and motion isolation in our overall mattress score, and we present these results using a simple colour system: green (5.0 and above), yellow (3.0–4.9), and red (2.9 and below). Cooling features aren’t part of the final rating, but we still use the same colour scale to show how each mattress performs. Firmness and bounce are more a matter of personal preference, so we display those scores in grey and exclude them from the overall score.
Mattress Overview
Quick Look |
Douglas Original |
The Casper |
Simba 2500 |
|---|---|---|---|
Price Range | $599 - $899 | $999 - $1,999 | $1,599 - N/A |
Firmness | 6.7 / 10 | 6.0 / 10 | 6.1 / 10 |
Standout Features |
|
|
|
Sleep Trial | 365-night trial | 100-night trial | 100-night trial |
Overall Rating | 9.9/10 | 5.8/10 | 6.1/10 |
BONUS OFFERS WITH PURCHASE! Buy any Douglas mattress today and get a FREE Comfort Sleep Bundle, 50% OFF All Sheets, and 15% OFF All Bed Frames and Bedding. See website for details > | |||
Product Details: Douglas Original
Douglas Original is a medium-firm foam mattress made to stay cool and comfortable in all sleep positions. It contours around your body, helps support your spine, and has good edge support and motion isolation. It's also made with eco-conscious materials like ecoLight® cooling gel foam and responsive Elastex® foam to help regulate temperature and relieve pressure points.
At just $799 for a queen, Douglas Original is one of the more affordable foam mattresses in Canada. It comes with a 365-night sleep trial, a 20-year warranty, and a free bedding bundle. You can also choose to upgrade to the Douglas Alpine or Douglas Summit models for extra features.
Product Details: The Casper Mattress
The Casper is an all-foam mattress with a medium-firm feel that should suit most sleep styles. It includes 3 layers of foam, designed to provide a balance of comfort and support. The mattress uses open-cell foam and perforated comfort layers to help release heat. It scored well for edge support and motion isolation during testing.
A queen size costs $1,499 and comes with a 100-night sleep trial and a 10-year warranty. While the cover isn't removable or washable, Casper sometimes includes a free accessory during sales. The mattress is made in Canada and is available both online and in-store through select retailers.
Product Details: Simba 2500 Mattress
Simba 2500 is a 12" hybrid mattress made with foam and micro-coils for extra airflow and support. It includes 4 interior layers: graphite-infused memory foam, 2,500 micro-coils, perforated transition foam, and a 7-zone support base. The mattress also comes with a breathable, hand-knit cover and CertiPUR-US® certified foams.
At $2,199 for a queen, it's priced higher than most online hybrids. Simba 2500 comes with a 100-night sleep trial and a 10-year warranty. But returns are exchange-only, and customers have to bring the mattress back to a Sleep Country store. There's also a $65 exchange fee. Instead of a refund, customers get store credit.
Get the winning mattress.
Mattress Sizes & Prices
Sizes Based on standard sizing. Individual mattress dimensions may vary. | Douglas Original | The Casper | Simba 2500 |
|---|---|---|---|
Twin
| $599 | $999 | $1,599 |
Twin XL
| $649 | $1,149 | $1,699 |
Full/Double
| $699 | $1,399 | $1,999 |
Queen
| $799 | $1,499 | $2,199 |
King
| $899 | $1,999 | $2,499 |
California King
| $899 | $1,999 | N/A |
RV (Bunk)
| $599 | N/A | N/A |
RV (3/4)
| $719 | N/A | N/A |
RV (Short Queen)
| $799 | N/A | N/A |
Prices are pulled from mattress brand websites or trusted third-party retailers. We check prices monthly to stay accurate. Prices on our site don't reflect any current sales or promotions. Learn more >
Mattress Construction
All three mattresses are built using a multi-layer foam or hybrid structure designed for comfort and support.
Douglas Original
- 1st Layer: 2" ecoLight® cooling gel foam to offer a memory-foam-like feel, which provides body-contouring comfort and pressure relief. The cooling gel infusion also makes this layer breathable and cool to the touch.
- 2nd Layer: 2" Elastex® transition foam, which adds a level of bounciness and responsiveness similar to latex, while being latex-free.
- 3rd Layer: 6" of motion-isolation support foam that provides support, stability, and significantly reduces motion transfer across the mattress. This high-density base helps to minimize disturbances from movements on the other side of the bed, which is one reason why all Douglas mattresses are known for their great motion isolation.
The Douglas Original mattress has a white mountainscape cover with a red zipper running along the sidewall. The top cover is machine washable, making it easy to keep the surface of the mattress clean and fresh. It's made with plant-based, moisture-wicking Infinitex™ fibres to help it stay cool and breathable throughout the night. This stretch-knit fabric is very soft, but also very durable.
The Casper
The Casper mattress has a sleek two-tone grey cover with a soft, woven top. It's designed to be durable and breathable, but it can't be removed for washing.
Simba 2500
- 1st layer: 1″ graphite-infused memory foam as a top layer that helps contour to your body while the graphite infusion works to draw heat away, supporting a cooler sleep.
- 2nd layer: 1″ micro-coils individually wrapped in (up to) 2,500 units designed to add breathability. They're surrounded by edge support foam to help with structure around the perimeter.
- 3rd Layer: 3.5″ polyurethane transition foam positioned in the middle of the mattress, which is meant to help reinforce edge support.
- 4th Layer: 6.5″ support foam base made of dense, perforated foam that provides a sturdy foundation and includes 7-zone support to help align the spine and support different areas of the body.
The Simba 2500 has a hand-knit cover featuring a bright white top and deep grey sides accented with blue trim. The cover is sewn on, so cleaning is limited to spot cleaning only.
Mattress Performance
Category | Douglas Original | The Casper | Simba 2500 |
|---|---|---|---|
Feel | Medium-firm | Medium-firm | Medium-firm |
Firmness | 6.7 / 10 | 6.0 / 10 | 6.1 / 10 |
Edge Support | 7.8 / 10 | 8.5 / 10 | 6.0 / 10 |
Motion Isolation | 8.3 / 10 | 7.9 / 10 | 7.7 / 10 |
Bounce | 3.1 / 10 | 2.5 / 10 | 3.9 / 10 |
Cooling Features | 5.0 / 10 | 2.8 / 10 | 4.3 / 10 |
In third-party engineer testing that we commissioned, Douglas Original, The Casper, and Simba 2500 all scored in the medium-firm range. This firmness level tends to work well for most people, whether you sleep on your back, stomach, or side.
All three mattresses also scored well for motion isolation and edge support. Motion isolation helps limit movement transfer if you sleep next to a partner or pet, and good scores mean fewer sleep disruptions from movement. Edge support provides added stability along the sides of the bed, which is helpful if you like to sit or lie near the edge.
Where Douglas Differs:
- Douglas has the best motion isolation score, coming in at 8.3/10. This makes this mattress ideal for light sleepers.
- It also earned a higher cooling feature score of 5.0/10, thanks to features like its moisture-wicking Infinitex™ cover, breathable Elastex® foam, and ecoLight® cooling gel foam. Its lower bounce means less surface disruption, which some people prefer.
Where Casper Differs:
- The Casper earned the highest score for edge support in this group at 8.5/10, which could be helpful for people who sit on the side of the bed or share their mattress with a partner.
- However, it scored the lowest in cooling features with a 2.8/10 and has a softer overall feel, which might not appeal to those who prefer a firmer sleep surface.
Where Simba Differs:
- The Simba 2500's hybrid build gives it a bit more bounce than Douglas or Casper, scoring 3.9/10 Some sleepers might prefer Simba's higher bounce for easier movement when changing positions or getting in and out of bed.
- It includes airflow-focused features like graphite-infused foam and perforated support layers, contributing to its cooling score of 7.7/10.
- It has the lowest edge support rating in the group at 6.0/10, and its return policy allows exchanges but doesn't offer refunds.
These third-party engineers apply a consistent testing process to every mattress using a detailed framework. Every mattress is tested the same way, whether it's foam or hybrid. Because these types perform differently, we rate them on separate scales to ensure the scores are fair and meaningful.
We believe independent testing is essential to producing reliable and meaningful comparisons. That's why all test results are reviewed and signed off by an APEGA-certified engineer, operating under a strict code of ethics.
We use the testing results and over 40 criteria to build our scoring methodology.
Tests and reviews without this level of professional oversight may be more prone to errors and unintended bias.
Delivery & Other Policies
Quick Look |
Douglas Original |
The Casper |
Simba 2500 |
|---|---|---|---|
Courier | FedEx | UPS | FedEx |
Shipping Fees | Free | Free | Free shipping on orders over $75 |
Delivery Timeline | 2–10 business days | 5–15 business days | 3–10 business days |
Sleep Trial Nights | 365 | 100 | 100 |
Return Policy | Free pickup and return, full refund | Free pickup and return, full refund | Exchange only with $65 fee; no pickup |
Warranty Years | 20 | 10 | 10 |
Douglas
Douglas ships through FedEx to most addresses across Canada, usually within 2–10 business days. Each Douglas mattress is compressed, rolled, and shipped in a box for convenient delivery. Shipping is free. Douglas also offers a 365-night sleep trial and a 20-year warranty, both among the longest in the industry. If you decide the mattress isn't right for you, Douglas will arrange for a free return pickup and provide a full refund.
Casper
Casper ships for free across most of Canada and usually arrives within 5–15 business days. The mattress arrives compressed in a box for easier setup. If you purchase through Casper's official website, you'll get a 100-night sleep trial and a 10-year warranty. Returns during the trial period include free pickup and a full refund. If you buy from a third-party retailer like Sleep Country, the return policy may only allow a one-time exchange with a fee.
Simba
Simba mattresses are sold and shipped through Sleep Country Canada. Shipping is free on orders over $75, with a $120 surcharge for some remote areas. Delivery usually takes 3–10 business days. The Simba 2500 arrives compressed in a box. Sleep Country includes a 100-night trial with purchase, but returns are exchange-only. You'll need to return the mattress in-store yourself and won't receive a refund. Instead, you'll get store credit. Simba also includes a 10-year limited warranty.
Company Background
Third-party review sites like the Better Business Bureau (BBB) and Trustpilot collect and publish customer feedback about companies and their products, and aren't controlled by the companies being reviewed. They offer a snapshot of overall customer satisfaction and highlight common issues shoppers might face. Checking ratings on sites like these can be a useful way for customers to make more informed purchasing decisions.
Douglas stands out here with a better Trustpilot rating and a higher BBB customer review rating score than Casper and Simba.
Third Party Sites Scores from brands' Better Business Bureau and Trustpilot profiles are factored into our overall mattress ratings. | Douglas | The Casper | Simba 2500 |
|---|---|---|---|
BBB Rating | |||
BBB Stars | 4.9 / 5 | 1.17 / 5 | 1.32 / 5 |
Trustpilot Rating | |||
Parent Company | GoodMorning.com | Sleep Country Canada | Sleep Country |
Year Launched | 2017 | 2014 | 2015 |
Get the winning mattress now.
Final Recommendation
Douglas, Casper, and Simba each have something to offer, but Douglas Original is the only mattress in this comparison that includes a full 365-night sleep trial and a 20-year warranty, giving you an entire year to test it out.
At just $799 for a queen size, it also costs significantly less than the other two options and includes a free bedding bundle with every order. Douglas Original combines strong third-party test results and a more flexible return policy at a lower price without compromising on comfort.
Our Winner:
Buy Douglas if you want...
- A 365-night sleep trial and 20-year warranty
- A queen-size mattress for under $800
- Great motion isolation and very good support
- A machine-washable top cover
- A mattress that comes with a free bedding bundle, including a sheet set, pillow(s), mattress protector, and pillow protector(s)
- Free shipping and returns across most of Canada
Other Beds You Might Like
Douglas Alpine
Price Range:
$799 - $1,099
Mattress Type:
Foam
Firmness Options:
Medium-firm
Country of Origin
The manufacturing origin listed here is based on the law label of the specific mattress we tested. Learn more >
Juno
Price Range:
$399 - $599
Mattress Type:
Foam
Firmness Options:
Medium-firm
Country of Origin
The manufacturing origin listed here is based on the law label of the specific mattress we tested. Learn more >
Logan & Cove Frontier
Price Range:
$999 - $1,499
Mattress Type:
Hybrid
Firmness Options:
Medium-firm
Country of Origin
The manufacturing origin listed here is based on the law label of the specific mattress we tested. Learn more >
The product details in each review reflect how the mattress performed at the time we purchased and tested it, as shown by the "Published" date.
Since brands can update their materials, pricing, or availability over time, we also note when the product was originally purchased, either directly in the article or on our disclaimer page, to maintain clarity and transparency.
If you see an "Updated" tag on a page with a more recent date than the published date, it simply means we've made editorial changes. It does not necessarily indicate any update to the mattress or its test data.
Finally, unless otherwise stated, any mention of where a mattress is made refers specifically to the product we received and tested.
More details >
Top Pick 2025
Douglas Original
Top-Rated Canadian Foam Mattress
- 365-night sleep trial, 20-year warranty, and free bedding bundle with purchase
- Comfortable cooling gel foam top layer, with convenient machine-washable cover
- Earns a high score for motion isolation
BONUS OFFERS WITH PURCHASE! Buy any Douglas mattress today and get a FREE Comfort Sleep Bundle, 50% OFF All Sheets, and 15% OFF All Bed Frames and Bedding. See website for details >
Sponsored Ad
Table of Contents
Save
Save